Freethought Activism

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence

Editor’s Note: This article first appeared in Mangalore Today

Extraordinary claims need extraordinary evidence, writes Prof. Narendra Nayak while delving on the controversial Made Snana issue.

Warning: This article contains graphic images

Loosely translated into English it means taking bath on left overs but a detailed one would mean rolling over the leaves on which others have eaten and discarded. Again, a lengthier one would be lower caste people rolling on the leaves on which Brahmins have eaten! This has been taking place since hundreds of years if some are to be believed. Again, if some others are to be believed, it is a time honored tradition which has sanction of ‘scriptures’. This happens in quite a few places and as a child I have observed the same when I used to go to temples with my mother. But, I am told that it was and is still an affair which happens between people of the same caste that is GSBs (Goud Saraswat Brahmins) performing this act on leaves on which the members of their own community have eaten.

But, what happened at the Kukke Subrahamanya Temple is something totally different. Here the scheduled tribe people performed this act on leaves on which Shivalli Brahmins have partaken food. This again brings to the fore many issues which have to be discussed in detail. This temple is, to put it mildly, not as popular as the one nearby at Dharmasthala. The latter being owned by a Jain has drawn more people particularly from the other side of the Western Ghats and subsequently has higher collections. The owner of this temple has been also running many capitation fee colleges and businesses. In order to compete with it, the management of the Subrahmanya Temple has been trying its best to get publicity. Its speciality is providing solutions for naga dosha which in loose translation means problems due to cobra or serpent trouble!

These problems could be anything from sterility to skin diseases. Once diagnosed the performance of proper prescribed rituals could result in relief from the associated problems. So, any one going there could be diagnosed with that. Since the dosha or the fault can carry on to several generations it could be said that your grandfather or great grandfather could have performed some act which would have caused harm or angered some serpent. So, that could be set right by performing some rituals which could expiate these sins and hence relieve the victim of the associated problems.

One usually sees a large number of people alighting from the train from Bangalore to Mangalore at the Subrahmanya road railway station which is the nearest one to this temple. So, the whole place thrives on the business of ridding people of the sarpa dosha! As already said it has been competing for popularity with the temple of Manjunatha at Dharmasthala which is paradoxically a Hindu temple owned by a Jain! Though the latter is far ahead in popularity, the former cannot be blamed for not trying its best! In fact they have provided ‘relief’ from the serpent affliction to quite a few VVIPs like Sachin Tendulkar, Aishwarya Rai, Amitabh Bachan to name a few. But despite all these the former remains far ahead in terms of popularity( in other words collection of cash).

So, the word has gone around that the ritual of rolling over the leaves on which Brahmins have eaten can cure a number of skin diseases and also other things like bestowing children on sterile couples. But, if one goes by the history of such practices, it looks more like a rite for the down trodden to perform to demonstrate their loyalty to the upper castes who have partaken food on these leaves. In this temple which is run by Shivalli Brahmins, their community is served separately and the others have to eat outside like all such places. There are instances where people have been forcibly evicted from the places reserved for this community! It has been done not just to the supposedly lower castes but even to Goud Saraswat Brahmins who though call themselves so are held in low esteem by these so called upper castes! So, behind these practices lies a simmering cauldron of caste politics. In fact these castes like Koragas have been subjected to inhuman practices like what was called as Ajalu. They were served meals on leaves on which Brahmins have eaten along with a clipping of a nail or hair, dancing before the procession of deities etc.which have now been banned. These things were done ostensibly to transfer the ‘bad luck’ caused by some inauspicious combination of planets to these people!

The reactions to this practice of made snana were diametrically opposite. The Dalit activists who opposed it were manhandled by the very people indignities against whom were being protested-malekudiyas who belong to scheduled tribe, attacked the Dalit activist Shivaram who was submitting a memorandum against this practice to the administrator of the temple and police were silent spectators to this outrage. The volte face of the government on this issue of first banning the ritual and then permitting it left much to be desired. More strange were the attitudes of the ministers. Some of the Dalit ministers opposed the ritual while those like Dr.V.S.Acharya supported it! There are many strong reasons why the latter is supporting it. Firstly, it is a temple belonging to Shivalli Brahmins the community to which he belongs. Then again there is a strong Hindutwa lobby supporting these primitive barbaric rituals which he wanted to please. He also puts forward many theories to support his contentions which deserve to be analysed in detail as Dr.V.S.Acharya is an MBBS graduate who has been trained to and is expected to follow evidence based, scientific system of medicine.

So, if he justifies such a practice on medical grounds as he did he owes a lot of explanations to the scientific community which should be forthcoming. In any scientific system of medicine any practice associated with the process of diagnosis or treatment should be subjected to proper scrutiny before being followed. So, statements like practicing made snana may cause formation of antibodies, have to be justified with proper evidence. The long winded explanation for this is that saliva may contain some bacteria, viruses or some such which could stimulate the production of antibodies and boost the immune system of those who roll on the leaves which have been used. Hahnemann, the father of Homoeopathy has been also quoted here. Well, if something has to be accepted for treatment on the basis of scientific system of medicine it should be supported by evidence.

So, we should advocate clinical trials to validate these claims and these could be as follows: 1.Making Brahmins roll over leaves on which Dalits have eaten. 2.Making Dalits roll over leaves on which Dalits have eaten. 3. Making Dalits do the same on which Brahmins have eaten and lastly do it with Brahmins on leaves on which they have eaten and then compare the anti body levels. As for his resort to Homeopathy, he should understand that it is not an indigenous system of medicine and that a number of double blind trials have shown that it does not work and it has been removed from the National Health Service in UK.

Again many other practices which have been now banned could have been given such justification like nude worship being needed to expose the skin to sunlight to get more vitamin D, child marriage helping to develop deeper bonds between the couples, widow burning being needed to protect them from misery, shaving their heads would protect them from lice etc. All these were well accepted practices at one time and have been now banned. If Dr.Acharya is a firm believer in this theory of antibodies being formed by this ritual he should start this practice himself and boost his own immune system too. Though one cannot agree with the arguments of those who oppose this – like it helps to spread diseases or transmits HIV virus, the practice has to be opposed if it is degrading a particular community that too one like the Malekudiyas who are a scheduled tribe. This system of performing the ritual on the leaves on which only one community have eaten is again violation of human rights of others who profess the same religion.

More to be condemned is the violence perpetrated on the activists who had gone to investigate the happenings. The perpetrators of this were honored as if they were heroes. These attempts to perpetuate the caste divide were supported by the victims themselves who allegedly threatened to stop their annual duty of decorating the temple chariot unless they were allowed to perform this degrading ritual of rolling over eaten leaves. This shows that either they must have been instigated or that their deep rooted superstitions must have scared them of the divine repercussions that would ensue if they ceased to perform this ritual.

It is a pity that even during these times where science has progressed to the level of identifying the micro organisms which cause leprosy that there are those who still believe that it is caused by the curse of a serpent and doing meaningless rituals like this can cure it. It is worse that there are ‘educated’ people in positions of power who keep trotting out excuses for these without a shred of evidence. For those who argue that it is for us to disprove such claims we quote – extraordinary claims need extraordinary evidence and that what can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

About the author

Narendra Nayak


  • Dr.VS.Acharya Karnataka’s home minister is a non practising medical graduate. He might have forgotten medicine long ago in the nitty gritty of politics. What we need to develop to thrive in caste religion and corrupt politics in India is not scientific temper and humanity [As prescribed in Article 51 of our constitution] but rationalising any superstition and it requires cognitive dissonance to the highest degree. But whether it is cognitive dissonance or pure hypocrisy is any body’s guess [I personally will go by the later]

    It is bane of our country that even the few educated and professionally qualified politicians just behave like their uneducated counterparts and go by the mojority opinion and dont have a voice of their own. I know Dr.Acharya and his Orthopedician son personally, on the personal level they look quite normal but i was astonished to see his true casteist face on this issue.Never expected a doctor to go to such lengths to rationalise such a barbaric custom [I loathe one human rolling on another humans leftover. It makes me puke in disgust] in the name of greatest quackery of all times namely homeopathy. While UK has banned homeopathy from its NHS after the Wirral commission report [Given the lack of evidence on efficacy and cost-effectiveness of homeopathic therapies, it is recommended that NHS Wirral does not commission homeopathic therapies]we in india are utilising our scant resources to promote quackery in the name of AYUSH. THere are big chains of homeopathic hospitals in India [Some claim largest chain of hopsitals in the world] which are advertising htemselves in print and visual media 24/7 with claims of treating any thing from low back pain to infertility to cancer and even AIDS [I still dont understand how a diluted sugar water can cure so many diseases where so many drugs are found wanting, if the power of palcebos is so strong , why take medicine at all]

    Religion is opium of masses, our govt instead of giving basic health care want to make poor people wants them to feel that because of their sins they are suffering and want to give them the opium of superstition that rolling on leaves will cure them. So much for propogating scientific temper and humanity.

    But i feel we should not get bogged down by the goons of higher castes and inept police but should continue to oppose this cruelty. By persistence and constant opposition in media we can put a stop to this inhuman custom. Hope many more saner voices like yours come forward and oppose this.

    This year for the first time Travancore devasom board has agreed that the MAKARAJYOTI in sabarimala is manmade fire. I hope all the devotees will see thro this game of creating false miracles to earn money by that temple. It is due to the efforts of rationalists and media awareness and our courts proactiveness that temple authorities had to come out with the truth publicly. I hope same thing happens with Kukke subramanya.

  • There is no point even investigating the “scientific merit” behind some outrageous practices. They are outright dumb, and in this case, even sinister. It can be argued that this is a case of perpetuating social injustice and humiliation; and that is in violation of the constitution of India.

    Case closed.

  • I happened to see this post as i was browsing the net. its a very shameful thing for the shivalli brahmins to claim their heirarchy even though LORD KRISHNA himself has proven to their own people in the sacred palce of Udupi that devotion is atmost important to please him. Even their guru Sriman Madhwacharya too has cleared in the scriptures that son of a brahmin need not be a brahmin and that son of a shudra need not be a shudra. if these shivalli brahmins cannot be mended by LORD KRISHNA AND SRIMAN MADHWACHARYA themselves, then who could do it? as about the saraswat community also being targeted , it shows the narrow minded selfish intend of the shivalli brahmins because the saraswat brahmins are also of the MADHWA lineage. why do these shivalli brahmins not see tha caste of the money that goes into their mutts? because the shivalli brahmins are not the types to let all their wealth for the mutts. when the konkanis and the shets can donate profusely and the wealthe can be accepted fOr the pooja of LORD KRISHNA, I dont think these shivalli brahmins are above SRI KRISHNA HIMSELF. I WOULD LIKE TO ASK IF THEIR IS A DIFFRENCE IN THE SRI KRISHNA IN THEM AND THE SRI KRISHNA IN OTHERS. KINDLY KNOW THAT THE PERSON WHO KNOWS THE ULTIMATE BRAHMAN IS A BHRAHMIN, NOT OTHERWISE. IF HE KNOWS THE GOD-ULTIMATE BRAHMIN, THEN THERE WOULD BE NO SCOPE FOR CASTEISM, WHICH IS NOTHING BUT VARNAS OF THE ANCIENT INDIA DIVIDE ON ECONOMIC DIVISION NOT THE CASTE DIVISIONS OF THE KALIYUGA

Leave a Comment