Categorized | Ajita Kamal, General News

Imagine No Religion

On the 7th anniversary of the attacks on the World Trade Center in New York, the two candidates vying for the most powerful job in the world are set to disgrace the site of the fallen towers in a political gesture. They will make speeches and call on the powerful emotions of patriotism and vengeance and they will proclaim again that they will not rest until the perpetrators are brought to justice.

Across the United States, people will remember the tragedy and mourn the loss.

But no political leader in all the democracies in all the world will utter the words that describe the real motivation behind the attacks that killed those people that terrible morning. RELIGION.

Forget about all the socio-political arguments. When it comes down to it, the one thing that makes an otherwise rational human being wish to leave this wonderful life for a fairy tale promise, is religion. 

The popular opinion is that we cannot blame religion; we can blame the individuals, we can blame their culture, we can even blame their particular religion, but no- we can’t blame religion in general! What is usually forgotten is that institutions can be worse than individuals. Benjamin Franklin was a good man. Jefferson was the kindest of persons. And yet, they both owned slaves. To quote Noam Chomsky (in a different context), “…you want to distinguish between the institution and the individual”. Slavery as an institution was evil, but the people who practiced it weren’t all bad. Similarly, people who practice untouchability are not inherently bad, it is the beliefs that organized Hinduism imposes on them that is the problem.

We could start changing things by recognizing the viral beliefs in our culture that lead to so much suffering. Let us hope that future cultures will look back at this period in history, in the same way we look back at slavery, and wonder how it was possible for such kind-hearted people to be tarnished by such an ugly institution as organized religion.

Share This Article: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Live
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • TwitThis

Related posts:

  1. Terrorism & Religion
  2. A Comment on Religion and India’s Poor
  3. Science Versus Religion: A Report From The World Atheist Conference
  4. Hinduism: Religion, Culture or Way of Life?
  5. Obsessive-Compulsive Religion
  6. “Defamation of Religion is not Racism” says U.N. - OIC Disagrees.
  7. Producing Priests (How Government Funded Educational Institutions Are Promoting Religion in India)
  8. A Rational Approach to the Problem of Obsessive Compulsive Religion
  9. What’s Religion Doing in the 21st Century?
  10. Religion in Music: Replacing God with Nature
  11. History of Religion
  12. Bollywood Sensibility ? - Part 2. A Different Khan

This post was written by:

Ajita Kamal - who has written 35 posts on Nirmukta.


Contact the author

4 Responses to “Imagine No Religion”

  1. Anon says:

    Please. Zeitgeist is complete BS. While I am not saying there isn’t anything fishy about 9-11, I believe that Zeitgeist is complete bull-honky.
    For one…
    I challenge you to provide proof of any ONE claim from the zeitgeist movie. Show me proof of all these religious icons they say are so similar to this ‘jesus’.
    I’m an athiest. I am a rational thinker. I saw zeitgeist and it made me ask questions. So I went on the hunt for answers and found none. What I did find is a site that will give you CASH MONEY! for proof of any claims in zeitgeist.

    The problem is that you believe whatever you want, and so does everyone else.
    The problem with that is that people are too accepting of what we are told, especially by media and RELIGION.
    Wake up and learn. Educate yourself, seek truth. Don’t trust the media, trust wiki-pedia, the library and yourself.

  2. Indian_the_patriot says:

    what ?

    ” Honestly…..do you really believe this had anything to do with religion…

    Any open minded person would see this was about money….not religion…in fact the above post seems like it was written by a close minded religious type..

    I personally remember watching cnn the morning it happend and welling up with emotion….until I saw the towers drop….then i was like???? buildings dont fall strieght down ….. then many videos have been produced since that back my thoughts….lose change 911…zietgiest…wake up…

    i agree many people have done many stupid things in the what the call call religion…. but people are people…and religion is religion….

    search for truth…
    and dont sweat the bullshit”

    woow………..9/11 conspiracy ? yes, its a conspiracy by deluded religious fanatics of al-qaeda, whom were the creation of imperialism for collapse of soviet. Though, imperialism, capitalism, fundamentalism are the elements for the root cause, religion is the explosive binding material of those elements.

  3. Ajita Kamal says:

    Which part of the post “seems like it was written by a close minded religious type”?
    Having an open mind does not mean accepting every kooky idea there is out there. It means that you are willing to evaluate the evidence rationally.

    I have little patience for 9/11 conspiracy theorists. Their case has been soundly refuted by legitimate scientists. It takes a very cynical person to believe in such a vast, bloody government conspiracy.

    It is your irrational defense of religion that is closed-minded to the evidence. Don’t get me wrong, there are indeed peaceful religions out there, but anyone who claims Islam and Christianity are not full of hate, is deluded.

  4. jleftbrane says:

    Honestly…..do you really believe this had anything to do with religion…

    Any open minded person would see this was about money….not religion…in fact the above post seems like it was written by a close minded religious type..

    I personally remember watching cnn the morning it happend and welling up with emotion….until I saw the towers drop….then i was like???? buildings dont fall strieght down ….. then many videos have been produced since that back my thoughts….lose change 911…zietgiest…wake up…

    i agree many people have done many stupid things in the what the call call religion…. but people are people…and religion is religion….

    search for truth…
    and dont sweat the bullshit

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Leave a Reply

By posting your comment you are agreeing to comply with our commenting guidelines

  • Popular
  • Featured
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe

Our Flickr Photos - See all photos

Nirmukta Quiz!

Welcome to the quiz section on Nirmukta!

This month's quiz is on Homeopathy in India.


Click Here

Click on Image

Astrologers Wanted

Nirmukta is looking for astrologers and astrology software to predict the year ahead for noted skeptics from around the world, as well as for the contributors at Nirmukta. If you are interested or have information that could help, please contact us using the form on the Contact Us page. We are interested in having Chinese, Western and Vedic astrologers demonstrate and prove to us the validity of their claims.

Reader Questions

Check out our Q & A section for advice and information from our panel of contributors and resident skeptics. You may use the Contact Form or email your questions to info@nirmukta.com. Anonymity is guaranteed on request.

Nirmukta Shoutbox

Last Message
1 week
 ago
  • Siddharth Singh : Prove it, Guest_1770.
  • Guest_1770 : god is real
  • Ajita Kamal : Not a good format for serious conversation. Perfect for drive by shootings..
  • Siddharth Singh : Hey 3360.. glad to have you around. Maybe you can register for this site (see below) and we can have the conversation going. Cheers.
  • Guest_3360 : guess not...
  • Guest_3360 : helloooooo?
  • Guest_3360 : is anyone online right now??
  • Guest_3360 : wow a shout box! awesome!!!
  • Ajita Kamal : Sid, my faith in Cheesecake gives my life meaning... You cannot prove it, you must experience the holy Cheesecake
  • Siddharth Singh : Ajita, you blasphemer! Cheescake is a false god.
  • Ajita Kamal : Cheesecake is my god.
  • amit waghmode : gagangiri baba is my god
  • Guest_3120 : I meant, "the onus of proof".
  • Guest_3120 : Deepak, please do a google search for "Russell's Teapot". The onus of belief is always on the believer.
  • deepak : please answer this simple question.How can you prove God does not exist
  • deepak : just like if someone only keeps looking at crows and tells that there are no swans existing on this earth, his whole observation is completely wrong. there is no basis for it.
  • deepak : just by looking at some fake relegionists we cannot say there are no real ones.
  • deepak : you all have told you are a disbeliever in God
  • Ajita Kamal : OK, let's bring that up at one of our meetings.
  • Siddharth Singh : Ajita, I think he means we should have a form to discuss rationalist books. We have that on the cards.
  • Ajita Kamal : @Last commentator: What exactly do you mean? Please use contact page!
  • emailtoid.net/i/31 : Exchanging information about intersting rational books
  • emailtoid.net/i/31 : I am thinking rational books forum in this site.
  • Samrat : Great Work Ajitha..
  • Ajita Kamal : Check home page for Nirmukta organization proposal!
  • GuestX : Everyone set for the conference?
  • tate : great work guys !!! keep it up
  • Guest_2879 : 456513
  • Ajita Kamal : 6 panelists!
  • shobhitg : Wow we have a shoutbox !
  • Siddharth Singh : Chris, it is at January 23, 2010, at 16:00 GMT (21:30 New Delhi, 11:00 New York)
  • Chris : Has the discussion date been fixed?
  • Guest_4340 : great site
  • Ajita Kamal : «link»
  • Ajita Kamal : Yeah, Qualiasoup rocks! I've found out he actually has a site

Login